Egypt threatened by full-blown economic crisis
It couldn’t have happened at a worst time. Without a government and amid clashes, Egypt needs to take immediate action to reduce further fallout, says Una Galani.
November 22, 2011 3:03 by Precious de Leon
Egypt finds itself without a government at the worst possible economic time. Amid deadly clashes, and with elections likely to be delayed, its financial situation cannot be ignored and requires immediate action. The pound is under pressure, investors are wary. Social spending is beyond the country’s means.
Taking action now could limit the fallout. But without a proper government, the odds this will happen are low.
The economy has huge vulnerabilities. The budget deficit is will reach 10 percent of GDP in 2011.
Waning tourism, shrinking foreign direct investment, and the central bank’s costly defence of the pound all have depleted Egypt’s foreign reserves by 40 percent, to $22 billion, this year. Egypt now has only three months worth of imports in liquid reserves and is under increasing pressure to let its currency devalue.
The immediate priority is to go back to the International Monetary Fund and take the $3.2 billion 12-month facility mindlessly turned down in the summer. Even that aid is now looking like a paltry sum compared to the size of the crisis. Egypt has low external debt, but its over reliance on domestic banks has driven T-bill yields up to 14 percent. And 22 percent of total government spending already goes to serving interest payments.
Subsidies — mostly on cheap fuel — soak up a further 33 percent of total spending. That is greater than spending on health or education, and benefits the rich disproportionately. Phasing out subsidies would show investors that Egypt is prepared to tackle its deficit and the population that the government is willing to start honouring its “social justice” commitment.
Egypt also needs to reform its taxes. The country currently has no tax on capital gains. Income tax doesn’t amount to more than 20 percent for most top earners — lower than the global average, according to theCarnegie Middle East Center. Corporate tax is also capped at 20 percent for most companies. Egypt may have many low-tax neighbours but many long-term investors might be willing to pay for their access to a big market.
Subsidy and tax reforms aren’t new ideas in Egypt. But with the economy now seen as broken, the important decisions that can’t wait for a full political transition might be easier to agree.
– Egypt’s cabinet offered to resign as violent clashes between security forces and demonstrators continued on Nov. 21 raising the death toll after three days of protests to 33 with many victims suffering from gunshot wounds.
– “The people want the fall of the marshal,” protesters chanted, referring to Field Marshal Mohamed Hussein Tantawi, Mubarak’s defence minister for two decades and head of the army council. Around 20,000 people were estimated to be on the streets.
– The military council did not say whether it would accept the resignation of the cabinet. A military source said it was seeking agreement on a new prime minister.
– In October, Egypt’s finance minister, Hazem el-Beblawi, said that some 33 percent of total government spending goes towards subsidies and another 22 percent towards interest payments on Egypt’s debts.
– Parliamentary elections are due to start on Nov. 28. Under the current timeline, presidential elections are not expected until 2013.
(The author, Una Galani, is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are her own; Editing by Pierre Briançon and David Evans)