Tale of two ports strains Iraq-Kuwait ties
Rival port projects face off across key access waterway; Iraqis fear Kuwaiti megaport will monopolise traffic; U.N. urges both sides to settle row through diplomacy - Reuters
July 2, 2011 10:24 by p.deleon
Sitting in a traditional black funeral tent near Iraq’s only outlet to the sea, businessman Sadiq Jaafar is mourning the “death” of his country’s biggest port — even before it is built.
For Jaafar and many other Iraqis, the long-delayed Grand Faw port project near the southern oil hub of Basra risks being killed off by a rival megaport already being constructed across the water by neighbouring Kuwait.
The Gulf ports dispute is straining ties because Baghdad fears Kuwait’s Mubarak port not only threatens competition that will crowd it out of trade from Europe and the Middle East but may also infringe on Iraqi territory, a charge Kuwait denies.
The neighbours share more than just a narrow sea lane access to the Gulf, but also a long, bitter history of disputes over oil, water and land rights where the region’s two great rivers, the Tigris and the Euphrates, sweep into the sea.
“This port won’t only cause Iraq losses, but it is killing us off and launching an economic war,” Jaafar, a board member of the Iraqi Business Federation’s Basra branch, said at the tent he has set up in the southern city in imitation of those used by Arab families to accept condolences during mourning rites.
Some residents of Basra, from where the bulk of Iraq’s oil exports are shipped, last month staged a demonstration against the Kuwaiti port, carrying banners which read: “Don’t block our sea lanes” and “No blocking of Iraq’s ports”.
The harbour quarrel has exacerbated sensitivities between Iraq and Kuwait which have ebbed and flowed since Saddam Hussein’s 1990 invasion of his neighbour. Iraq’s troops were expelled by a U.S.-led force, months after Saddam denounced the colonial-era border and declared Kuwait Iraq’s 19th province.
“The issues are minimum in some ways, but they have taken on outsized proportions because of the principles and history they represent to the parties,” said Ken Pollack, director for the Saban Center for Middle East Policy at the Brookings Institute.
Iraq has been planning for more than two decades to build a large new deep-water port on the Khawr Abd Allah waterway — opposite Bubiyan island, where Kuwait is building its port.
Iraq’s Grand Faw megaport scheme has been successively delayed largely because of the wars Iraq has lived through — with Iran in the 1980s, the invasion of Kuwait in 1990 and the war and sectarian conflict that followed the 2003 U.S.-led invasion that toppled Saddam, who was hanged in 2006.
Iraq has only a sliver of coast, squeezed in between Iran and Kuwait. Umm Qasr, one of four Iraqi commercial ports but its only deep water one, handles 80 percent of Iraq’s imports, including grain for a huge public food ration programme.
Umm Qasr is already one of the most expensive ports in the world for shippers, and importing firms complain of being asked for heavy bribes, of poor service and high handling costs.
“Mubarak port will block Umm Qasr port and cut the sole maritime artery that Iraq’s ports rely on. It will close the naval maritime channel leading to Umm Qasr and deprive Iraq of its legitimate right,” Captain Kadhim Finjan, a naval expert and a senior official at Iraq’s state-run ports company, said.
UN MONITORS DISPUTE
Kuwait denies this, saying it has assured its Iraqi neighbours that Mubarak does not encroach on Iraqi territory and will not hinder traffic in the shared, constricted waterway.
“Our port is not even in international waters, but is built on Kuwaiti territory, under Kuwaiti sovereignty and far from the navigation path that Iraqi ships use to get to Umm Qasr,” the undersecretary of Kuwait’s Foreign Ministry, Khaled al-Jarallah, told reporters recently in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.
But many Iraqis, including former transport minister Amer Abdul Jabar, say the planned 14,000 ships-a-year handling capacity of the Kuwaiti megaport under construction will stifle business and traffic for the Iraqi ports, including Grand Faw.
He urged Iraq’s government to respond by denying Kuwait permission to transfer goods by railroad from Mubarak through Iraq northwards to Turkey.
Kuwait has said it will not violate an existing U.N. Security Council resolution that guarantees freedom of navigation in the waterway between the two neighbours. U.N. officials are closely monitoring the ports dispute.
“The United Nations Assistance Mission for Iraq encourages both parties to address issues in the framework of the bilateral committee headed by both the Foreign Affairs Ministries of Kuwait and Iraq,” the mission said in a statement.
Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki’s government has agreed with Kuwait to set up a joint technical committee to study the issue of the potentially competing Mubarak and Grand Faw ports.
IRAQI RED TAPE
The design contract for the 2.8 billion euro (around $4 billion) Iraqi Grand Faw port project has been awarded to an Italian consortium led by engineering company Technital.
But progress has lagged, not helped by Iraq’s inconclusive March 2010 election that was followed by months of political wrangling before a coalition headed by Maliki could be formed.
In March, Iraqi Transport Minister Hadi al-Amiri said a tender for the building of the Grand Faw port would be floated by the end of the year. He has since threatened to resign unless his government immediately finds funding for the port project.
But analysts say that while Iraq, still struggling to emerge from years of war, chaos and sectarian conflict, has dithered and delayed, Kuwait is forging ahead with the construction of its own port, thanks to a more streamlined investment process.
“Kuwait implements its projects and programmes freely, while in Iraq, red tape kills a lots of projects like the Grand Faw Port,” Abdulrahman al-Mashhadani, an economist at Baghdad’s al- Mustansiriya University, said.
Iraq has some of the world’s biggest oil reserves and has ambitious plans to ramp up its oil production and exports, but experts say that unless it rapidly expands its infrastructure such as ports these plans could remain a mirage.
But supporters of Grand Faw see Kuwait’s emerging port obstructing those plans. “It’s provocative and dirty competition,” said former transport minister Jabar. (By Aref Mohammad; Additional reporting by Khalid al-Ansary in Baghdad and Asma al-Sharif in Jeddah; Writing by Khalid al-Ansary; Editing by Pascal Fletcher)