Do you support Tanmia’s proposal to ban private companies in the UAE from sacking Emiratis?

The results are in.
February 22, 2009 2:31 by Aarti Nagraj
The financial crisis is here, and several companies are firing people. Accepted fact. But is it right for the government to decide who may and may not be fired based on nationality? According to most of you, no. The majority of respondents, 61.5 percent, believe that everyone’s job is equally important, and that the proposal to ban private companies from laying off Emiratis is not acceptable.
While more than 5 percent did feel that the government should protect its nationals, 29 percent feel that the law should only be enforced in the public sector, not in the private sector.
Unfortunately, the government doesn’t agree. Last week, the Ministry of Labor said that private sector companies will face legal action if they sack Emiratis who have not violated the labor law. The latter constitutes non-performance of basic duties, and committing mistakes which result in substantial material loss for the employer, reports Gulf News. Company are not allowed to use the economic slowdown to fire Emiratis.
The ministry says it will enforce a ban on issuing new work permits to companies that do not comply, until a court verdict is passed.
The solution? Join the 4 percent of our respondents who answered “Whatever. I don’t care.”
More on Cover Story
-
BlackBerry opens first regional store
-
Nabbesh.com appeals to the masses
-
Cobone founder: ‘Best we’ve ever been’
-
Mile-high tower fit for a prince
-
Saudi Arabia Says MERS Coronavirus Kills Four More
-
Qatar Airways expands fleet
-
Fast route to prosperity, say Middle East’s wealthy
-
Iranians put hopes for change in pragmatic insider
-
Facelift for Middle Eastern corporate culture
-
Sharjah Police: ‘Don’t give money to beggars’
-
Saudi Arabia plans to block WhatsApp within weeks
-
EgyptAir plane diverted after “fire” threat
-
MERS coronavirus claims another life
-
‘Seven-star’ promotion
-
Finances strengthening but risks in Dubai – IMF
-
Five most viewed financial products
-
Economic, social pressures behind Kuwait crackdown on foreign workers
-
‘Dubai embodies the essence and ethos of a World Expo’
-
Back to pre-crisis peak
-
Qatar PM to be replaced
Lately on Kipp
-
BlackBerry opens first regional store
-
Here’s something to ‘tweet’ about
-
Golden Systems Wins ‘Best Contribution’ Award from KINGMAX
-
Nabbesh.com appeals to the masses
-
UAE Regulator Says Bourse Merger Would Have “Many Advantages”
-
MenaITech participates in sponsoring Entrepreneurial Excellence in the Knowledge Economy Conference
2 Comments
Here’s something to ‘tweet’ about
Sharjah Police: ‘Don’t give money to beggars’
Fighting the world’s biggest killer
Twist and shout
“Your customers aren’t fools”
Behind the curtain of Simone Heng
Chatting with the man behind Dubai City Pass
A business discussion with the author of ‘Connect The Dots’

































This certainly is not a wise decision. Instead of supporting “private” employers who have helped so much in the devleopment and sustainance of Dubai, the government is trying to favour locals, who are not as professional as their expat counterparts. Anybody ever to Dubai knows very well they professionalism and efficiency of locals at work, whether they are at government or private institutions. Its the expat community who has so far burnt its blood for development of Dubai economy. They were not appreciated when Dubai was reaping gold and when hard times came, expats have to bear the consequences. Not fair at all.
If Tanmia or Dubai Govt thinks all laws are for the expats, why not deport them all and let the “locals” do all the work from labourer to the shop keeper.
Well i think with as little as 10% of population are locals, it is fair propose such request. after all as xpats we had a much better opportunity than what we had back home!
thanks dubai and its residents for housing as many nationalities as possible.