Register for our free newsletter

 
 
Latest News

My Name Is Khan vs. Slumdog Millionaire

One has picked up countless Oscars. The other features the undisputed ‘King of Bollywood’. Both are business success stories. But which is best?

 

My Name is Khan is set in post-9/11 America, and focuses on the discrimination faced by Muslim character Rizwan Khan, played by Bollywood megastar Shahrukh Khan. The film was directed by Karan Johar, and filmed on a reported budget somewhere in the region of INR38-55 crore ($8.55 million – $12.37 million). FOX Star Entertainment bought the rights for the film for a reported INR1 billion ($22.49 million), making My Name is Khan the second most expensive Bollywood film ever made.

Editor's Score 1

Slumdog Millionaire tells the story of an eighteen-year-old orphan from the slums of Mumbai, who reflects back on his tumultuous life while competing to win INR20 million on India's Who Wants to Be a Millionaire TV show. Reputed British filmmaker Danny Boyle directed the film, which cost an estimated $14-15 million to make, a modest budget by Hollywood's standards.

Editor's Score 0
 
VS

At the beginning of March, My Name is Khan was named the highest Bollywood earner in the Middle East, with $3.3 million in box office collections. It shattered the record for the biggest opening of a Bollywood film in the UAE, with some 135,858 tickets sold in the first four days of its release. Worldwide, the film grossed around $40 million.

Editor's Score 0

Despite its relatively low budget, Slumdog Millionaire grossed a massive $365 million worldwide, plus another $32 million in US DVD sales – making it a clear winner in terms of profit. The film saw box office takings of $311,673 during the opening week in UAE.

Editor's Score 1
 
VS
Stars
 

Shahrukh Khan is the undisputed ‘King of Bollywood’, and has a global fanbase of over 3.5 billion people. Enough said.

Editor's Score 1

Slumdog Millionaire featured child actors with little or no experience – yet their incredible performances made them stars. But there was much controversy last year after the parents of the child stars claimed that they were paid as little as $770 to appear in the film. Established star Anil Kapoor plays the game show host in the film – but only after director Danny Boyle asked Shahrukh Khan to play it. Khan declined the role.

Editor's Score 0
 
VS
Awards
 

My Name is Khan hasn’t won any major awards to date. But considering the film was only released in February 2010, there is some hope that it will win some honors later in the year.

Editor's Score 0

Slumdog won eight Oscars last year – including Best Motion Picture of the Year, and Danny Boyle picked up the gong for the Best Achievement in Directing. It also won seven awards in the 2009 BAFTA Film Awards, along with around 100 other awards and 50 nominations.

Editor's Score 1
 
VS

While My Name is Khan did not attract as much controversy as Slumdog, a couple of incidents did prompt some negative headlines. One was when Shahrukh Khan was stopped for questioning by authorities at Newark Airport in the US – which some claimed was a publicity stunt for the film (a charge that Khan dismissed as "lowdown and cheap”).

Editor's Score 1

Aside from the issues over how much the child stars were paid, Slumdog attracted a number of other criticisms, notably regarding how it portrays Indian society. Following its release in India, some alleged that the film fuels Western stereotypes about poverty in India and that it peddles "poverty porn".

Editor's Score 0
 
VS
Reviews
 

My Name Is Khan has received generally good reviews. The New York Times called the film “an affecting fairy tale about the perils of goodness”, while the Los Angeles Times describes it as "a potent, energetic heart-tugger.” Users of The Internet Movie Database (IMDB) gave the film 7.1/10, based on 5,162 votes.

Editor's Score 0

Slumdog Millionaire has been applauded by Western commentators. Wall Street Journal critic Joe Morgenstern refers to the movie as “the film world's first globalized masterpiece.” The Los Angeles Times said it is “a Hollywood-style romantic melodrama that delivers major studio satisfactions in an ultra-modern way”. While both films got some good reviews, Slumdog clinches it: IMDB users gave it an impressive 8.4/10, based on 163,876 votes.

Editor's Score 1
 
VS
Goofs
 

‘Goofs’ – defined as errors “that shouldn't have made it into the movie, but somehow got by the editors” – are popular talking points among film geeks. My Name is Khan contains only one ‘goof’, according to The Internet Movie Database. The plot hole concerns a scene at the beginning of the film, when the character Rizwan is shown to be scared of all yellow things. But later on, he is shown carrying a yellow pumpkin and also holding a yellow placard.

Editor's Score 1

Slumdog Millionaire is full with plot holes, factual errors and revealing mistakes. In fact, more than 30 ‘goofs’ are listed on IMDB. One is when the character Jamal is beaten and tortured by police – only to be seen in the next scene in the Who Wants to Be a Millionaire TV studios with his bruises magically healed. Another is when you hear actor Dev Patel's British accent when he tells the host (Anil Kapoor) in the bathroom that he will "not be a million-ahe.” What an Indian!

Editor's Score 0
 
VS

Editor's Score 4

Editor's Score 3
 
VS
 

18 Comments

  1. Judy on April 28, 2010 12:32 am

    You forgot title. MNIK has a better title than the oft-claimed derogatory “slumdog.”

     
  2. pakistani on April 28, 2010 6:49 am

    King Shahrukh Khan is the king of world… Shahrukh Khan should be compared with Hollywood, not lower level Bollywood.

     
  3. Azim Baqar on April 28, 2010 7:03 am

    My Name Is Khan better than Slumdog Millionaire

     
  4. Bharti on April 28, 2010 7:56 am

    SRK is the best
    All his movies rock
    Slumdog Millionaire is gud but it can not beat any of Shahrukh’s movies.

     
  5. MADDY on April 28, 2010 8:09 am

    MY NAME IS KHAN – MOVIE OF DECADE

     
  6. fasi on April 28, 2010 8:34 am

    SRK is Best and his performance was extraordinary in MNIK

     
  7. Megha on April 28, 2010 8:35 am

    Slumdog Millionaire was a baaaaddd movie. In comparison, even Singh is King was better. So, MNIK is miles ahead of Slumdog.

     
  8. Link on April 28, 2010 9:10 am

    I’m going to be as honest and unbiased as possible.

    My name is khan was a good movie. It had an interesting story, good acting, and you cared for the characters. The moral of the movie also made sense and was poignant. It was both a critical and commercial success. The only major flaw was that certain scenes really slowed down the movie and took away from the experience (the hurricane scene).

    Slumdong Millionaire also had an interesting story. Some of the performances were good: Irfan Khan and Frida Pinto stood out in my mind. You cared for the characters at some points in the movie. However, the movie had some definite flaws as well. They were trying to sell poverty and the using the plight of Indians to increase the relevance of the characters in relation to their setting. They commericalized and exagerated Indian poverty as if all of India is “slumdog”. Furthermore, the movie was not very meaningful, outside of the message that true love conquers all, the fact that Jamal won the lottery is not inspiring and it is foolish for people to laud the movie for this device. Most of my friends in USA told me that they did not like the movie because it was overly dark and was simply not compelling. Ergo, it was a very mediocre film. It won awards because of 2 reasons: it was made to win awards (not for people to enjoy) and Hollywood feels charity towards certain groups every now and then: one years they gave best actor and best actress to blacks (although no black had one either award in almost 40 years).

    My name is khan wins.

     
  9. jasleen on April 28, 2010 9:29 am

    mnik is a far better movie than slumdog, whether u talk abt the story, acting, music or direction. moreover, presence of shahrukh khan makes it a more lovable and watchable movie than any other across the globe.

     
  10. Rohail on April 28, 2010 3:58 pm

    My name is khan, the movie of all time!

     
  11. RORRKY MIKONCHA on April 29, 2010 1:39 pm

    Ya! both the film are good only, we can’t simply measured a film by the budget it incurred but by moral and senses that is creates, both the film have enough ground for becoming a hit.

     
  12. RORRKY MIKONCHA on April 29, 2010 1:45 pm

    Ya! both the film are good only, we can’t simply measured a film by the budget it incurred but by moral and senses that is creates, both the film have enough ground for becoming a hit. Simply Best the two.

     
  13. Seum on April 29, 2010 9:12 pm

    SRK is Rock & his acting is amazing. He is the king of bollywood so My Name Is Khan better than Slumdog Millionaire.

     
  14. LUCKY on May 1, 2010 10:30 pm

    MNIK is far better movie with messege. SRK is global star.

     
  15. kp on May 5, 2010 9:08 am

    mnik shud must hav to win oscar…..film of the decade…….not very much entertaining but vry much 2 learn..n..the act of srk n kajol was awsome.really gr8.4 me it is best 4 oscar….

     
  16. Shan on May 12, 2010 9:36 am

    Let’s see.
    First there is SRK.
    Second he is acting as a patient with a disease and doing it perfectly.
    And there is Kajol. Best actress to take best out of SRK.
    Most importantly they are addressing a global issue which took an ugly face after 9/11
    Well having an ultra star cast and addressing a global issue and doing it magnificently I think you dont have to look too far for the best film ever Bollywood has produced upto date.

     
  17. Abhishek on May 12, 2010 12:05 pm

    MY NAME IS KHAN—- MOVIE OF THE MILLENNIUM.
    SRK IS THE KING OF THE WORLD.AND KAJOL IS THE QWEEN OF THE WORLD.

     
  18. joe on January 17, 2011 5:37 pm

    of course my name is much beter than this slummovie

     

Leave a Comment